Cultural appropriation in pop music goes way beyond Gwen Stefani

  • Gwen Stefani not too long ago got here underneath hearth for saying “I am Japanese” in a brand new interview.
  • Stefani is only one of many pop stars who’ve been accused of cultural appropriation over time.
  • Insider spoke to specialists on race and advocacy about this aggressive pattern in pop music.

Pop music has a cultural appropriation drawback, and Gwen Stefani talked about it once more this week.

Stephanie introduced the subject again to the fore once more by telling him that Asian American journalist in a current interview, “I am Japanese.”

Throughout an interview with Attract journal, Stefani was requested to mirror on the early Harajuku period, which was criticized for Attraction to Japanese aesthetics and the personification of her backing dancers – 4 Japanese and Japanese girls often called the Harajuku Women. Stefani has additionally been criticized for Capturing African, indigenous and South Asian cultures Prior to now.

“if [people are] I will be criticized for liking one thing lovely and sharing that, after which I feel it is not okay,” mentioned Jessa Marie Callure, Attract’s senior editor.

pop music “repeated offender”

Robert BucherLecturer within the Asian American Research Program on the College of Pennsylvania and Department Chair Affiliation of Japanese American Residents of PhiladelphiaHe informed Insider he was “appalled” by Stephanie’s current feedback. He’s additionally fast to notice that she is way from the one wrongdoer.

“Pop music normally appears to be as a lot a repeat offender as it’s an artwork kind that tends to commercialize and acceptable Asian cultural aesthetics for the aim of profiteering,” mentioned Bucher. “We see this over and over.”

In truth, Nicki Minaj’s 2018 music video was titled “Chun Li”. Parrot accused of “insulting Asian fetish”. Coldplay and Beyoncé He launched India as “a white particular person’s fever dream” in 2016’s “Hymn for the Weekend”. “Lean On” by Main Lazer (2015) and “Bounce” by Iggy Azalea (2013) has confronted comparable scrutiny. And the record goes on.

Buscher known as particularly Katy Perry’s efficiency of “Unconditionally” on the 2013 American Music Awards, which noticed her sporting a kimono, holding an umbrella, and doing groovy dances.

Bucher defined that “the lyrics are about loving somebody unconditionally after which dressing up considerably much like what a Japanese geisha appears like.” “[She’s] Reinforcing these concepts about Asian girls being submissive and demure. Issues.”

Kate Berry

Katy Perry performs on the 2013 American Music Awards.

Christopher Polk/AMA2013/Getty Pictures for DCP

Reinforce destructive and harmful stereotypes

Like Perry’s 2013 efficiency, Stefani’s employment of 4 Harajuku women, Bowsher mentioned, performs up “the concept of ​​a sexually obtainable, commodified Asian feminine physique.”

Whereas the harajuku women usually accompanied Stefani to pink carpet occasions and picture shoots, the ladies didn’t converse in public; Korean-American comic Margaret Cho described her position in Stephanie’s life as “ Present vocalist. ”

in 2004 efficiencyThe dancers could be seen forming a circle round Stefani, getting down on their palms and knees.

“Simply from the physique language and the bodily gestures, it visually describes what the hierarchy is on this state of affairs,” Bucher mentioned. “That is type of white supremacy—Gwen is the blonde-haired, blue-eyed mid-point pop star and he makes use of this Japanese aesthetic, I feel, to have fun that in some methods.”

“Alarming degree” of racial abuse

The industrialization of girls of coloration might have devastating penalties.

As Insider’s Kristi Valerie Hwang reported beforehand, so have the Asian American and Pacific Islander communities Dealing with an “alarming degree” of racial abuse and violence Because the starting of the COVID-19 pandemic. in 2021, A sequence of shootings at Atlanta-area spas left eight individuals lifeless, together with six Asian girls. The shooter reportedly shouted, “I need to kill all Asians.”

Bowsher defined that whereas the pop star’s illustration of Asian girls doesn’t carry the burden of those horrific crimes, it could be contributing to a sample of anti-Asian racism and misogyny. which have existed in the US because the nineteenth century. “It is simply one other approach to push that ahead into the following technology,” he mentioned.

Different pop stars have additionally been accused Treating marginalized girls like propstogether with Miley Cyrus, whose 2013 album “Bangerz” was deeply rooted within the sounds and aesthetics of hip-hopa style created and carried by black artists.

In music movies and performances round this time, Cyrus would usually dance and Surrounding herself with black girls, and typically seize their butts or different elements of their our bodies. Bucher described this as a “horrible objection”. (She later I apologize for her “insensitive” behaviour).

Miley Cyrus 2013 Vmas Performance

Miley Cyrus performing on the 2013 MTV Video Music Awards.

Michael Loccisano/FilmMagic

The dangers of cultural appropriation are nice, mentioned Wealthy Richardson, a professor of Africana research at Cornell College, particularly given the historical past of colonialism, imperialism and slavery that black girls have confronted on this nation.

“What’s at stake when one is just not actually part of that tradition’s historical past—nor sharing its traumas or the burdens related to that id—is the potential for commodification and exploitation” on the expense of the people who find themselves the tradition’s authentic creators, Richardson mentioned.

The distinction between inspiring and nurturing

Some pop stars have responded to accusations of appropriation by insisting they’re merely “followers” of the tradition, or Claiming that their actions have been born out of “love and appreciation”. “[It] You need to be okay with being impressed by different cultures as a result of if we’re not allowed, that divides individuals, proper? “

Many artists have been in a position to efficiently and respectfully specific this “love and appreciation”. Beyoncé’s 2022 Album ‘Renaissance’ Celebrated Incorporating queer themes and genres in a respectful manner, though she is a straight lady. singer too A tribute to the numerous cultures throughout the African Diaspora on her “Black Is King” visible album.

Roka Hatua Sar White, assistant professor at Boston Conservatory in Berkeley, defined.

Of Beyoncé’s current work, White mentioned it is clear she’s completed her “due diligence.”


Beyoncé in “Hymn for the Weekend” (2016) and a press picture for “Renaissance” (2022).

Coldplay/Youtube Mason Paul

“Objectively talking, I feel there may be nothing fallacious with this sort of cultural trade so long as the particular person doing it has been given permission to take action, and it’s an trade of need on each side,” he added. “It turns into a extra advanced situation when one particular person or group in that dialog has much more energy and privilege than the opposite.”

White defined that cultural appropriation happens when somebody borrows the practices, concepts, or any factor of one other tradition for monetary or materials acquire. However an artist can use their fame to boost consciousness of marginalized tradition.

Madonna, for one, capitalized on the ballroom scene by releasing “Vogue journal. Nevertheless, the tune additionally lifted the group by way of its help, because it gave platform For dance flooring, performers and Donation to black and LGBTQ the explanations.

In Stefani’s case, it’s clear that she has benefited from Japanese tradition along with her many Harajuku clothes traces, merchandise and singles, however it’s unclear if Stefani’s adoption has returned something to Japanese tradition.

“It is about transcendence, appreciation and honor inside cultural exchanges,” White mentioned. “The query is how do you come the favor?”

Leave a Comment